Have mask, will travel!
Tip #1 - get the travel insurance. Especially right now, when a negative covid test is required to re-enter the US. And especially especially if you'll be around a lot of people at a group event like a conference or convention. I had to get a negative test on Friday to be able to fly home on Saturday. If I'd been stuck at a hotel for the additional ten days a positive test requires, that would likely cost me another $1000-$3000 just for accommodation. Travel insurance will normally reimburse that cost. Check your policy to be sure.
Tip #3 - arrive early. Travel is draining even if all you're doing is sitting on a plane for seven hours.
Getting onto a "normal" sleep and food schedule as soon as possible will help you recover faster. We both took the days after the signing as a vacation - she and her family stayed in Scotland to tour while I flew to Sweden to spend a few days with a friend.
Tip #5 - find the fun. The first half of this trip was legitimately work for both Pippa and me. She's not a huge extrovert, so signings like this - even though she loves meeting readers - can be really draining for her. I brought skin care face masks that we put on before popping into her reader group on Facebook for a live chat with members on Wednesday night. We looked absolutely ridiculous and had a blast chatting with her Pipsquad.
The hotel we stayed at had a "thermal suite" that we booked for Thursday evening before we even really knew what it was - we just figured it would be a big hot tub and that sounded relaxing. It turned out to be a three-hour experience that I'd recommend to anyone staying at the hotel! There were half a dozen wet and dry saunas, two programmable showers that cycled through hot and cold water while running a light and sound show to imitate a thunderstorm, a giant indoor pool, and a heated, jetted pool outside on the rooftop.
We booked tea on a yacht with author pal Lucy Score and Mr. Lucy, I made my own gin blend, and Pippa got to meet up with friends she hadn't seen in years.
Work travel doesn't have to be all work, even if you're going to Omaha for a sales conference rather than Scotland for a book signing. Ask the hotel staff for a trendy restaurant recommendation, choose a convertible rental car instead of the sedan, check out a local museum, browse an independent bookstore. Find the fun no matter where you are and you'll bring home great memories as well as some souvenirs.
Looking for a romance writer starter kit? I’m here for you! Over the next few months, I’ll be sharing my favorite resources and tools to help you kick off a new writing career or level yourself up.
Let’s start this series with the OG – Gwen Hayes’s Romancing the Beat.
This is my absolute favorite recommendation to new writers who are trying to figure out how this whole story thing works. We’ve known how to read for decades and we’ve been writing since grade school…so why is writing a book so flippin’ hard?
You know that a croissant is simply dough layered with butter then baked, but without a recipe to follow, if you’re not already an experienced baker, you probably don’t know how to make that dough or layer that butter or possibly even how to cut and roll the dough to create that traditional croissant shape.
That’s where Gwen Hayes comes in. She’s the master baker (author and editor, in this case) walking us through the step-by-step process of baking up a delicious story.
Romancing the Beat is the book I recommend to all new romance authors. It clearly outlines what plot and emotion “beats” (a point of action in the story) should be happening in a typical romance. This road map guides writers through each step of the tale, from the meet-cute to the happily ever after. The book doesn’t dictate what happens in the plot (the external action that’s going on) but it does provide a template for how the characters should be acting/reacting at each beat. The fact that RtB is based on characters rather than plot is critical because romance is a character-driven story.
RtB dives deeper than a simple outline by explaining why each beat is important, how that beat propels the story forward, and then offering plenty of examples and fun ‘80s references.
It’s a quick read, only around 100 pages. And Hayes’s writing voice is light and fun even when she’s delivering insightful material.
Depending on which process works best for you, there are several ways to utilize the book. Use her beat sheet (she offers a PDF and Scrivener template on her website, and Plottr has an RtB template as well) to outline your story before you write. Or write first and employ the beat sheet as a checklist during revisions to ensure you aren’t missing any important bits in your story. You can even check your favorite romance novels from other authors against the beat sheet and see how closely they align.
RtB is not a rule book. It’s a guide. And there are lots of fabulous romance novels out there that don’t follow Hayes’s beats. But if you’re a new author still learning how to story, this is your Romance 101 course.
Have you read Romancing the Beat? Do you use it to outline your book?
You want to write a romance novel. Or you’ve written your book and you know that self-editing or revision is a thing you’re supposed to do. Or you’ve finished your manuscript and feedback from your first readers – critique partners, beta readers, your bestie – makes it clear that the story is great but there might be something missing.
Welcome to the six foundational elements of a romance novel!
As a professional romance editor, I’ve basically dedicated my life to this genre (#noragrets), and this article covers the story components that I look for on the first pass of an edit. Before you go wild perfecting your comma placement and hiring a proofreader, let’s make sure your story structure is strong enough to support this beautiful world you’re building for your characters.
The romance industry gets a lot of not great publicity and haters like to call our genre tropey as though it’s a bad thing. Our stories are accused of being simplistic and poorly written and those statements often come from people who have never read a good romance novel.
I contend that in fact romance is more difficult to write than a mystery or thriller novel because we have at least two main characters who require a full story arc. We aren’t writing just one character who has a goal, encounters obstacles, and has to complete an emotional transformation along the way to “the end” – we have to do all that work for no fewer than two people!
And that makes romance doubly hard to write. Feel free to quote me the next time someone says something mean about romance in your presence.
Our genre is also rife with subconscious expectations from readers, so the better you understand how romance novels work and what your audience wants even if they don’t realize it, the stronger your stories will be.
There are six foundational elements every novel should have in order to hit that reader expectation button. Both characters should have a clear profile in the story of:
I want to read a book, so I go to my bookshelf and grab the one I want and sit down to read. That’s boring. There’s no conflict. Nothing interesting is happening to keep a reader engaged.
I want to read a book, so I go to my office, but when I enter the room, I find that my entire bookcase is missing. Ooooh, a mystery! Where the heck did a six-foot-tall bookcase disappear to?
Those other four elements incorporate with the goal and conflict to create an infrastructure that supports your entire story. They are the yeast and egg and butter in your basic recipe for hardtack that turn it into a rich, glorious brioche.
Here’s a template to help you imagine how the six elements work together: Character wants GOAL because of MOTIVATION but CONFLICT is preventing her from getting it. If she doesn’t get the goal, STAKES will ruin everything she’s worked for. Her FLAW causes her to make bad decisions at key points until she finally learns ARC and earns her happily ever after.
Can you plug your own story elements into that template? Does it help you understand a high-level outline of your story?
Are you as fascinated by this structure stuff as I am? Enroll in my online course that dives even deeper into these foundational elements. The self-paced class includes a more detailed explanation of each element and how it functions in story, plus lots of examples to help clarify and reinforce the information. There are also recordings of live discussions with two authors – one using the six elements to plot a book and one with Stefanie London as we review how she used the six elements in one of her published books.
You can implement these core story components at any point in your writing process – plot in advance, keep the elements in mind as you write, or use a checklist on your revision to ensure you’re hitting all six points in the story after you’ve finished your first draft. Just be sure that they end up in your manuscript before you get to the copy editing or proofreading process so you don’t end up rewriting significant chunks that you’ve already paid someone to spell check.
Have you ever done a perfect average day exercise?
If you have no idea what I'm talking about, here are two good articles...
But if you don't want to take the time to read the articles, the summary is: envision and write down your ideal random weekday as a way to make achieving it a goal for the future. And don't worry. You can participate in this as much or as little as you like!
Maybe you're working during this ideal day, maybe you're independently wealthy at this point, maybe it's something in the middle. All of those are valid desires. This isn't a bucket list or dream vacation day where you wake up at South Base Camp on Mt. Everest or when your butler knocks on the door of your over-water hut in Bora Bora. It's just a normal Tuesday.
I'm not into meditation or visualization or manifesting, so this always feels a little woo-woo to me, but I do see the benefit of it and I've been steadily moving toward attaining my perfect day for several years even though I never completed the exercise.
Step 1: Write down/Type out what happens on your perfect day. Do this however it makes sense to you - like a list of events, like a schedule hour by hour, ordered from most important to least, scribbled down however you think of each moment, whatever.
Step 2: Arrange your day chronologically. That doesn't mean you have to start it at 6am, just start with whatever happens first during your day, whether you're waking up at sunrise or after lunchtime.
Step 3: Make no moral judgments on the things you've written down. If your perfect day means you lie in bed and watch game shows until 11am and someone else's has them out the door for half-marathon training at sunrise, that has nothing to do with the character or morality or "laziness" or "productiveness" of either of you. If Drew Carey makes you happy, then keep watching The Price is Right!
Step 4: Assign emotions or feelings where appropriate to each item on your list. Pointing out something you want to avoid is legitimate - I don't want to feel rushed - but positive connections are stronger - I want to enjoy my first cup of tea in peace and quiet.
Step 5: Use three different colored highlighters to mark which things you're already doing, which you feel are easily attainable in a reasonable amount of time, and which are your stretch goals.
Step 6: Rewrite your list as a narrative and save it somewhere you'll remember to look at it at least a few times a year if not weekly or daily.
Step 7: Choose one goal from your list that you want to work toward achieving and give yourself a timeline to do so.
Step 8: Join The HEA Club to share your perfect day with other romance authors and support each other on your journeys!
Like I said above, do as much or as little of this as you want. Because I'm a to-do-list, action-oriented, check-the-box kind of girl, rewriting my day as a story isn't useful to me. It's just extra words. But I do love a bullet point!
So here's mine...
Instead of a single goal, I'm forming a habit around putting money into savings each week. That doesn't directly relate to anything in my "perfect day," but being a nomad is definitely in the perfect day. And since my car is 11 years old, I don't want to be driving it all over the US. So I want to save money to buy a new car, at which time I'll pack up the dog and we'll start our new nomad life.
Tell me about your perfect day!
I'm updating my editing prices for 2021, and you can see the breakdown below. Individual coaching will still cost $100/hour, and other projects will remain priced dependent on scope.
Anything invoiced on or after January 1, 2021 will be...
Developmental edit: $0.01/word
Line edit: $0.012-$0.02/word **quote will be provided after review of manuscript pages
Copy edit/Proofread: $0.007/word
Critique/Beta read: $0.006/word
For an easy example of the price changes, if you've done a developmental edit with me this year on a manuscript that's 50,000 words, the price in 2021 will go up by $75.
The biggest change here is that the line editing price now ranges. I'll request a sample of pages from the middle of the manuscript to determine the depth of work involved in the line edit, then I'll send you the per word cost.
I'm still offering discounts on multi-pass edits, so be sure to mention if you want a second round of editing when you contact me.
This article is one in a series on finding and working with a freelance editor. Part 1 details the types of edits available for novels, part 2 is where to find an editor, part 3 is things to consider when deciding on who you want to work with, part 4 is knowing when you're ready to start editing, and this is the final post, part 5.
You did it! You finished a book and you researched editors and you’ve sent your baby off to be critiqued by a professional and oh no was that the worst decision ever?!?!
Deep breath :) It was a great decision and a necessary step toward getting your book published.
Necessary though it may be…the editorial feedback will incite emotions. Maybe it breaks your heart, or maybe it is exactly what you were hoping for. It could be devastating or enlightening. How the editor’s comments and suggestions feel to you depend on many things – how the feedback is framed, how you accept constructive criticism in general, how personally or not you feel about something you created, your understanding of and belief in the editing process, and so much more.
When you get your feedback from an editor – or anyone, really; this pertains to betas and critique partners and agents and anyone else you’ve asked for opinions – read through it, and if it makes you feel anxious or defensive or hurt or anything negative, just walk away. Give yourself some distance from the MS and this other person’s response to it. Take some time to vent to an author-friend if it might help. When you come back to read the feedback again, try to not take anything you consider negative as a personal attack and keep in mind that this is only one person’s opinion.
Think of your book like a recipe. You'd probably want someone to tell you that you added a cup of baking powder to your cookies instead of just a teaspoon, right? Or if you’ve offered your friend who hates raisins an oatmeal raisin cookie, she probably isn’t going to like it. Just because you created these cookies doesn’t mean that mistaken measurements or personal tastes make you a bad cook or a less-than person. You are not the thing that you created.
You are a wonderful, beautiful, valid person regardless of how you write (or cook).
Also, know that all the examples I offer in this post are ones I’ve seen several times. So if you’re reading this and thinking, “She’s talking about me,” even if I am, you’re definitely not the only one!
I’ve worked with authors who love that I give them detailed critiques about how to improve their stories and what is lacking structurally, and I’ve worked with authors who completely shut down and don’t know what to do next. Both are valid responses, as is every other response along that spectrum. However you feel about feedback is how you feel. And there’s always a way forward.
Comparison can be debilitating and I hope you’re able to learn to avoid it. Please don’t compare yourself to other authors. Everyone has a different writing journey, different backgrounds and experiences, different networks of people and knowledge to support them. And please please please with whipped cream and a cherry on top don’t compare yourself to authors who have five or ten or twenty books published. They’ve been doing this for years. You wouldn’t walk into a new job on Monday morning in a new role you’ve never performed and assume you should be just as savvy about this company as the CEO, right? It’s the same with writing fiction. This is a new job you must learn even though you’ve been writing and reading since elementary school.
That’s all the philosophical and emotional and ephemeral stuff. Now let’s get into the practical techniques of reading, acknowledging and accepting feedback.
So you’ve done the first read of your editorial letter, you’ve called your bestie to cry or rage, and now it’s time to hitch up your pants and get to work. Let’s do it!
Hopefully you have an editor who is telling you what they love about your story as well as where they see opportunities for improvement. Bask in the positives and be realistic about the opportunities. Often editors will point out something that isn’t working for them and explain why it doesn’t work, but leave the actual changes up to the author. They may even offer a few examples of how the revised section might develop to give you some ideas or different perspectives. If you agree, that’s awesome! Go ahead and make those revisions. If you don’t understand what the editor is asking for, then contact them to get clarity. And if you disagree with their suggestions or their reasoning, you don’t have to make the change!
You’re an indie author, which means you are not obligated to take a single revision from your editor. (If you're traditionally published, there are more rules.)
I don’t recommend going into the editing relationship with that as your banner, but it’s the truth nonetheless.
Editors are here to guide you, but we don’t know everything, we can’t fix everything, story is highly subjective, and these characters belong to you. You make the final call on the revisions in your book.
Once you do start to revise, I recommend doing it in a couple different rounds that go from wide and overarching story aspects like character arc or goal (anything included in my Six Foundational Elements) to narrow and focused like repetition in the writing or lack of detail.
Revisions take as long as revisions take. I’ve known authors who can plow through a developmental edit in a week and others who take three months. Again, writing is no place for comparison. You just do the work that is required is improve your story. While you're doing that, you're learning and growing as an author with every revision and every new book.
And because I’m me – and you should be expecting this if you’ve read this whole series – once you’ve finished your revisions, it’s time to celebrate! So break out that champagne and toast yourself to getting one step closer to publication.
This article is one in a series on finding and working with a freelance editor. Part 1 details the types of edits available for novels, part 2 is where to find an editor, part 3 is things to consider when deciding on who you want to work with, and this is part 4.
There are steps you can take before the manuscript goes to your editor to ensure we (editors) are receiving the best, cleanest, strongest version of your story. I recommend self-editing before the editor gets the document because it gives us the chance to delve into your story and writing style to really polish the final product and help you level up. If you send us your first draft as soon as you type The End, we may end up spending time on things you could have fixed without paying us, and we don’t have the opportunity to do any polish work since we’re focused on basic story structure.
First, finish your manuscript and put it away. Get that happily ever after wrapped up then hide the document from yourself for a few days or even a few weeks to let your brain take a break from it. You need some space to find the objectivity to edit your own work. Read other books, catch up on some TV shows or movies you’ve been wanting to watch, maybe even start a new writing project. However you do it, ignore that finished manuscript for a little bit. I promise that your brain is still noodling on aspects of that story in the background while you’re focused on other things. That’s how brains work.
When you’re ready to start self-editing, open that document and do one of the following…
1. Print that bad boy on paper and grab your red pencil!
2. Change the spacing, size and/or font in the document
3. Forward it to your Kindle or phone, wherever you can read and take notes (Word has a mobile app, if that's useful for you)
Basically, you’re tricking your brain into thinking this is a brand-new document that it’s never seen before. Your brain isn’t quite that gullible, but I promise that seeing the story in a different format does help it feel new.
If you didn’t do this while you were writing, step one is to outline your story structure and ensure you’re hitting all the story beats. I break structure into six foundational elements of goal, motivation, conflict, character arc, flaw, and stakes in my online course. Gwen Hayes reviews beats in her book, Romancing the Beat, which include story points like the meet cute, adhesion, and the dark night of the soul. Editor Jami Gold offers a spreadsheet (scroll down to find the romance-specific one) that calls the beats by different names than Gwen uses, but it’s the same format and it includes a formula to let you know approximately where in the story by word and page count each beat should fall.
Once you know your structure is sound, you can use one these books as a guide to edit your own work – Intuitive Editing or Self-Editing for Fiction Writers. Both books will walk you through big-picture story aspects as well as tighter line-editing tasks.
Welcome to your second draft! Celebrate it! Self-editing and revising means that you’ve accomplished twice as much as many new authors who finish the first draft and immediately fire it off to an editor. You now have a stronger, better story and your editor definitely appreciates the work you’ve put into it.
Next, you can send your revised manuscript to beta readers or critique partners. Keep in mind that these folks should not be your close friends or family members unless those people also happen to be widely read in your genre and are willing and able to give you critical feedback. Your mom loves everything you do, so she is likely not a good beta reader candidate.
If you have the opportunity to learn a bit about your betas or CPs, try to find out what they focus on or notice most often when reading. Ask them what they love about your genre and what frustrates them in the books that they don’t end up liking. Some readers keep track of timelines in their heads, and if you mess up ages or days of the week, they’ll catch it. Others adore deep characterization, where they feel they really get to know the main characters, their personalities, their backstories, and their thought processes. Still others may be sticklers for grammar and good at pointing out misspellings or clunky sentence structure. There are readers who want a tightly-paced novel, so if it slows down too much or gets boring, they’ll notice immediately that the pace is lagging. However, your beta or crit group shakes out, try to have different types of readers giving you feedback so you don’t end up with three people who only point out your misplaced commas.
Be specific about what feedback you’d like from each of them when you give them the manuscript. Online you can find lists of questions you can ask betas to answer, if you feel that’s appropriate.
When you receive the feedback from your betas or CPs, take it with a grain of salt. Everyone has an opinion about something, and just because they say it, doesn’t make it correct. But do remain open to their critiques – you’ve asked them to provide feedback because you trust their reader instincts, so don’t ignore everything you don’t agree with. Take some time to consider the snags they are pointing out and decide whether revising your story with their points in mind will ultimately strengthen your story. If more than one person is pointing out the same thing, it's probably something you should look a little deeper at.
Some famous author or editor said – basically – that others can point out where something isn’t working in a story, but their suggestions on how to fix it aren’t usually the right answer. Only the author can actually resolve the issue. That’s why my editing comments and letters generally offer a lot of questions and examples rather than a flat order of “Do A to fix B.”
Woohoo! You’re on your third draft! Celebrate some more! It’s a lot of work but I promise it’s worth all the time and effort in the end.
Next, run that baby through a free online editor like the one in Word or Grammarly to catch any lingering grammar or spelling mistakes. These programs aren’t perfect and they certainly throw plenty of false positives, but I use Grammarly when I copy edit since human eyes and brains are fallible as well.
And now, finally, your manuscript is ready to go to your editor!
If this long-ass blog post isn’t clear enough, this self-editing process can take weeks or months to complete. When you book a specific date with your editor, keep the schedule in mind and be sure to give yourself enough time to do a couple rounds of revisions before the editor expects the document.
Especially for new authors, I don’t suggest setting or announcing a hard release date until your book is at the copy edit or proofread stage. Often you have no idea just how much work may be involved in your own revisions or what the editor is going to suggest. Maybe you can turn around their suggestions in a few days, but I regularly see new authors taking two to three months to work on the revisions from my developmental edit. And if you have children or a day job, all calendars should just be lit on fire because you know how impossible it can be to schedule writing around them.
The editor has your manuscript and now it’s time to celebrate again! You’ve done an incredible amount of work in writing this book!
This is a series on finding and working with a freelance editor. If you missed the earlier articles, check out these links to learn what types of editing are available and where to find editors.
There are several considerations to keep in mind when you are evaluating editors, and every author will have a different arrangement of priorities. Some people have a strict budget they must adhere to while others may want to focus on the personality of the editor they will be working with. There is no right or wrong answer on which aspect is most important, there’s only the issue(s) that is most critical for you.
Regardless of the order, these are the points I suggest you examine.
Your editor should be experienced editing in your genre. Each style of book – romance, memoir, thriller, essay – is packed with conventions that, if ignored or overlooked, can result in bad reviews, poor word-of-mouth, and low sales. An editor who is well-versed in your particular genre will help ensure that you’re not blindly missing or trampling over any reader expectations.
Editing can be expensive. A developmental edit on a 75,000-word manuscript could run anywhere from $300 to $3,000 depending on the editor you’re working with. The Editorial Freelancers Association has a page of recommended rates, but there are certainly editors out there charging way more and way less. To be honest, the romance community often charges on the lower end of the scale, but there are still huge variances even in our genre. Know your budget and be realistic about what you can afford.
How and when does the editor take payment? Do they require a deposit? Do you pay in full, or half when you submit the manuscript and the other half when the edits are complete? Is any portion refundable? What if you aren’t happy with your edits? Do they offer a payment plan? Do they take payment via PayPal or Transferwise or check or bank transfer or credit card or gold bullion?
Some editors present contracts or agreements for authors to sign and others use the emails you’ve exchanged as an informal statement of work. What are you comfortable with? Would you prefer to sign a contract or would you consider that a hassle?
5. Editing process
Proofreading and copy editing are pretty straightforward, and the vast majority of editors will edit in Word with Track Changes on or in Editing mode in Google Docs. Both applications allow you to see the changes that have been made and either accept or reject each individual edit. Line edits could include an editorial letter, or they may only have inline changes in the document. A developmental edit and a critique may be detailed completely in an editorial letter or might include comments in the document. Some authors appreciate a phone call after the edits have been delivered to talk through the changes and take the opportunity to ask questions. Others want a few days or weeks to process the suggestions and revise on their own without any additional input from the editor. If you aren’t sure of your process yet, ask the editor what their availability is after the manuscript is delivered for you to follow up with questions or requests.
If you have a specific timeline that you’ll need your edits completed by, then I suggest finding your editor well in advance. It’s not uncommon for editors to be booked out three, six, or even twelve months in advance. Rush jobs may be available but are often significantly more expensive. Also be sure to ask what the turnaround time is for an edit. Once you deliver the manuscript, does your editor plan to get it back to you in four days, two weeks, or a month? And don’t forget to schedule enough time for your own revisions before the next round of edits. I have a couple clients who can churn out a second draft on a developmental edit in four or five days, but the majority of my clients take anywhere from one to three months to fully revise their manuscript.
Evaluate the personality and communication style of editors through their websites and their emails with you. Do you want to spend hours of your day reading this person’s thoughts about your manuscript? If you get a sample edit from them, do their suggestions feel empathetic, implementable, and realistic? Do they offer encouragement and explanations or examples? Are their responses to your emails timely and professional?
As I mentioned earlier, these aren’t in a particular order of most or least important. You’ll make that determination based on your own needs. But each point is important to consider in your overall evaluation of editors.
Part 2: Editors in the wild (AKA – Where to find them)
So you understand the different types of edits a manuscript may need and that there are lots of editing skill sets to choose from because you read part 1 of this article.
But how do you track down one of these mythical beings? Read on, my friend, and I’ll tell you where we hang out. (Hint: it’s the bar at writing conferences.)
The best way to find an editor? Ask your writing buddies for referrals. Just like when looking for a new doctor or a new job, referrals from friends and colleagues are indispensable. Though not every author-editor pairing will be a match made in writerly heaven, asking friends for recommendations gives you the chance to learn more about the working and communication style of the editor before you ever contact them.
If the referral track isn’t working for you, then next I recommend checking out the copyright and acknowledgments pages of the books you love and respect. Often, authors thank their editors for the work they’ve done, and some indie authors will list their editors (and cover artists and formatters!) on the copyright page.
Still looking? Facebook has approximately eleventy bajillion groups for writers. Join some! Make some new author friends. Ask in the groups if people have editors they recommend. If you write romance, check out the Romance Editor Q&A group to get started.
Online searches work too! I probably get one inquiry a week through my website where the author says they simply googled some combination of romance+edit/coach and my site came up.
As you’re looking for editors, be sure to find professionals who know your genre. There are lots of unspoken “rules” in genre fiction that you simply don’t know if you don’t read widely in that genre. And though it’s okay to break rules in writing, it’s best done when you know what the expectation is and flout it intentionally. Ignorance of the standards often just angers readers and makes them throw your book at the wall or – worse – leave a bad review.
Once you’ve narrowed your list of potential editors down to your top three or so, ask them for samples! This will give you a chance to see how they work, evaluate their communication style, and decide if you mesh as a team. Some editors charge for samples, some charge and put that amount toward your final invoice if you book with them, and some will do a sample for free. Some proofreaders won’t offer sample edits because proofreading is relatively clear cut, but other types of editors usually will. Some editors will request pages from the middle of your manuscript since that’s usually been through fewer rounds of perfecting than the first chapters, but some will take first pages also. There's a lot of flexibility around samples.
A compassionate editor will always give you positive feedback about your story as well as making clear, actionable recommendations on what can be improved. Avoid anyone who only tells you what you’re doing wrong.
And there’s my two-part series on finding an editor for your novel. Stay tuned for more posts about working with editors, things to consider (like cost and schedule), and the emotional gut punch that your first editorial letter will probably be.
Part 1: What does an editor actually do? (AKA – Do I really need an editor?)
You’re writing a book. Or maybe you’ve finally typed The End on your manuscript. Congratulations!
Now, it’s time to find an editor.
You can actually do this at any point in the process. You don’t have to have a finished manuscript (MS) to research, communicate with, or even schedule an editor. Though I do recommend being self-aware enough to know whether you can stick to a deadline if you book that editor before your MS is done.
So, what’s the first step to finding an editor?
You must understand what the different editing passes are, how they affect your MS, and who performs them. Editing skills come in all shapes and sizes, and many editors prefer to specialize in a certain type of edit or even a particular type of story. Take me, for example – I only work with romance authors.
The first type of edit a book needs is focused on content.
A content editor reviews your story as a whole. In general, they don’t care if you have typos or your character changes eye color in chapter five because they are making sure that you have strong characterization and dire stakes, a clear goal and ever-rising conflict in your book. They ensure your plot makes sense and follows the guidelines of your genre – if it’s romance, the people fall in love by the end; if it’s mystery, the crime is solved and the bad guy is caught; if it’s thriller, the pacing stays fast and keeps readers on the edge of their seats.
A content editor may advertise their services as a content edit, a developmental edit, or a substantive edit. These three terms mostly mean the same thing, but request clarification if you’re not sure exactly what an editor is offering.
And before you ask…
(Warning: soap box)
Yes, you need a developmental edit. This is where cranky Editor Jess comes out, because I see new authors needing to save money on the production costs of their book, and I totally understand that, you guys, but if you’re not putting out a quality story, you’re not going to get the sales you need to be able to afford to keep writing. Yes, some people (like the old Amazon scammers) released not great books that made lots of money, but that was because they also paid thousands of dollars in advertising to make sure they were casting the widest net in finding readers. If you can’t afford a developmental edit, you likely can’t afford $10,000 in advertising either.
There are ways to make a dev edit more affordable if you have a tight budget. I’ll write a post on that one of these days too. But please don’t skip this step in your production process!
(/end soap box)
Because a content edit deals with the whole story, it doesn’t make any sense to edit the actual words on the page until you know your plot is solid. That’s why content is step one. It’s a waste of time and money to check the spelling in Chapter 1 when you might end up removing that whole chapter.
As we go deeper into the manuscript, a line edit is the next level. This is also sometimes called a substantive edit, so again, ask your potential editor for specifics on what their services are. Line edits are still looking at your story, but this time it’s more about writing style and how you convey the story. At this point, the editor is considering your pacing – do you have a lot of white space on the page for a fast-paced scene? Do you slow down and give the reader a chance to breathe after a particularly thrilling scene? Are your characters interesting or relatable? Does the voice of the writing match the character you’ve created, their life experience and education and career? Are your chapters ending on hooks that entice the reader to keep turning pages rather than set the book down?
After the line edit is the copy edit. Now, we’re finally at the step that many people think of when they hear the word “editor.” The copy edit is all about the technical stuff – grammar, syntax, punctuation, and spelling – plus consistency and sometimes fact-checking. The copy editor has an ear for repetition, so if you’re repeating words or phrases or even sentence structure too often, your copy editor will point it out and may offer suggestions or simply edit the document to make changes. The copy editor is also on the lookout for that eye color change in chapter 5 and other story inconsistencies as they correct misspellings and misplaced commas and confirm the dates of real-life events you mentioned in the MS.
And finally we get to the proofreader. I always always always recommend that this be a new person, regardless of how many other people have worked on the MS thus far because you want a fresh set of eyeballs looking at your writing for this last step. No editor is going to guarantee they will catch all the typos in your MS, so having more than one person looking for those typos is essential.
Some editors offer manuscript critiques or assessments as well, and those are often similar to a developmental edit – they are focused on story, not grammar – but in a lighter style. My critiques, for example, are usually a scaled-back version of an editorial letter that outlines the two or three aspects of the story that are working really well and the three or four that could use some additional strengthening.
Keep in mind that not all editors perform each type of edit. It’s not uncommon to find people who only work on content edits, or only on copy editing and proofreading. Some editors may also decline to do more than one or two passes on an MS. I usually max out at two – a dev and maybe the copy edit after the author revises. I know that if I try to go through the MS a fourth time (because I do two rounds on the dev), that I’ll miss glaring typos because I’ve seen the document too many times already. My brain will automatically fill in correct information where it’s actually typed wrong or simply missing.
And there we have the different editing passes. This has turned out to be way longer than I expected, so check out part 2 for where to find editors in the wild.
Don't expect anything on a set schedule, but when I have something interesting or useful to share, I'll post it here. Also, as an Amazon Associate I earn from qualifying purchases.
Join for editing tips, book recommendations, co-working invites, and more, and I'll send you a link to my 10 Editing Hacks course for free! I'll never share or sell your email address, and you'll probably hear from me about once a month.
You have successfully joined my subscriber list. If you'd like to follow me on social media as well, check out my website for links.